Pizza Lover's Guide

Expiration: 5 years after purchase


Included Venues

See locations on an interactive map.

Angelo's
Angelo's at 305 Main St, #307 in Evansville, IN is a cozy, inviting spot known for its warm hospitality and classic Italian-inspired menu. Enjoy handmade pasta, flavorful pizzas, and seasonal specials in a welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere. Perfect for a quick lunch, relaxed dinner, or a casual gathering with friends.
Azzip Pizza
Azzip Pizza at 2121 N Green River Rd in Evansville offers fast-fired, hand-tossed pizzas with a focus on fresh ingredients and bold flavors. From signature pies to customizable options, guests can enjoy a quick, craft-pizza experience in a convenient, welcoming space.
Azzip Pizza
Azzip Pizza at 8850 High Pointe Dr in Newburgh, IN, offers fresh, customizable pizzas made with high-quality ingredients in a modern, fast-casual setting. Enjoy to-go or dine-in options, with a focus on bold flavors and quick service.
Azzip Pizza
Azzip Pizza at 4660 N First Ave in Evansville offers fast-fire, chef-inspired pizzas with a specialty menu of handcrafted pies, fresh toppings, and quick-take options, perfect for a flavorful, convenient meal.
Azzip Pizza
Azzip Pizza at 5225 Pearl Dr in Evansville, IN offers fast-fired, craft-inspired pizzas with crisp crusts, creative toppings, and house-made sauces. Enjoy quick, casual dining with convenient online ordering and fresh ingredients in a welcoming, modern setting.
Casey's Dugout
Casey's Dugout at 2900 Lincoln Ave in Evansville, IN offers classic Casey's convenience with a welcoming, neighborhood feel. Enjoy a quick coffee, fresh bakery treats, and reliable fuel, all in a friendly stop that's perfect for a quick bite or a convenient pit stop.
Deerhead Sidewalk Cafe & Bar
Deerhead Sidewalk Cafe & Bar is a cozy, inviting spot at 222 E Columbia St in Evansville, IN, blending casual cafe vibes with a laid-back bar atmosphere. Enjoy craft coffees and light bites by day, and refreshing cocktails, local craft beers, and live music by night, all in a friendly, neighborhood setting that welcomes lingering conversations and sunny sidewalk dining.
Show more
DiMaggio's Italian Pizza
DiMagio's Italian Pizza at 3848 N First Ave in Evansville serves classic, handmade Italian-style pies crafted with fresh ingredients and family-inspired recipes, delivering bold flavors and warm hospitality in a cozy, welcoming setting.
Dontae's Highland Pizza Parlor
Dontae's Highland Pizza Parlor is a welcoming bistro-style pizzeria nestled at 6669 Kratzville Rd in Evansville, IN. Known for its handcrafted, brick-oven pizzas topped with fresh, locally sourced ingredients, the parlor offers a cozy atmosphere perfect for casual dining. Enjoy classic favorites like margherita and pepperoni, alongside inventive specialty pies and crusts tailored to every palate. Friendly staff, quick service, and a warm, neighborhood vibe make Dontae's Highland Pizza Parlor a go-to spot for pizza lovers and families alike.
Show more
Kipplee's
Kipplee's at 2350 E Division St in Evansville, IN offers a welcoming cafe experience with a delicious café menu, local vibes, and friendly service—perfect for grabbing a quick bite, enjoying a rich coffee, or gathering with friends.
Little Italy Restaurant
Little Italy Restaurant is a cozy, family-friendly eatery nestled at 4430 N First Ave in Evansville, Indiana. Known for its warm hospitality and classic Italian favorites, the menu features handmade pasta, zesty sauces, wood-fired pizzas, and comforting tiramisu. A welcoming neighborhood spot, Little Italy offers generous portions, brick­-oven aroma, and a friendly atmosphere perfect for casual dinners, celebrations, and comforting weekend meals.
Show more
Lombardi's New York Pizza & Wings
Lombardi's New York Pizza & Wings offers classic, hand-tossed pizzas and savory wings in a lively Evansville spot. Located at 3311 N Green River Rd, this slice of New York-style flavor brings bold toppings, crafts a warm dining vibe, and delivers steady, satisfying bites for dine-in, takeout, and casual gatherings.
MOD Pizza
MOD Pizza in Evansville offers fast-fired artisan pizzas with a made-to-order, one-price-izza concept. Located at 6401 E Lloyd Expy Ste C-102, Evansville, IN 47715, this modern, casual spot serves customizable artisan pizzas and salads in a welcoming, crave-worthy environment.
Pangea Kitchen
Pangea Kitchen on 111 S Green River Rd in Evansville offers a vibrant culinary experience featuring globally inspired flavors, fresh ingredients, and a welcoming atmosphere that celebrates diverse cuisines.
Pangea Pizzeria Downtown
Pangea Pizzeria Downtown is a vibrant neighborhood spot located at 401 NW 2nd St Ste A, Evansville, IN 47708. Known for handcrafted stone-fired pizzas, fresh ingredients, and a welcoming atmosphere, it offers a diverse menu that blends classic favorites with inventive toppings. Enjoy a cozy dine-in experience, convenient takeout, and friendly service in the heart of Evansville.
Show more
Parkway Pizza
Parkway Pizza at 3911 Broadway Ave in Evansville blends classic Italian flavors with a friendly, neighborhood feel. Known for its crispy crusts, generous toppings, and signature pies, this welcoming spot offers quick bites, savory slices, and comforting favorites perfect for a casual meal or family night.
Pizza King | Evansville, IN
Pizza King in Evansville, IN, sits along IN-66 in Newburgh and serves classic, crave-worthy pies with a hometown touch. Known for its signature crust, hearty toppings, and friendly service, this local favorite invites families and friends to share in a warm, casual dining experience. Whether you’re craving a traditional pepperoni, a veggie-loaded slice, or a hearty specialty pie, Pizza King delivers comforting flavors and a slice of Midwestern hospitality.
Show more
Roca Bar
Roca Bar is a lively neighborhood spot located at 4600 Washington Ave in Evansville, IN. Guests can enjoy a welcoming ambiance, handcrafted cocktails, and a rotating menu of familiar favorites. Whether you’re stopping in for happy hour, catching live music, or unwinding after a long day, Roca Bar offers a friendly vibe, attentive service, and a inviting place to connect with friends and neighbors.
Show more
Spankey's Una Pizza
Spankey's Una Pizza is a cozy Evansville favorite known for its classic, crowd-pleasing pies and welcoming neighborhood vibe. Located at 4404 W Lloyd Expy, this family-friendly spot serves hot, neatly topped pizzas with a focus on friendly service and dependable flavors, making it a convenient and tasty stop for lunch or dinner.
Spankey's Una Pizza Downtown
Spankey's Una Pizza Downtown is a welcoming slice of Evansville charm, nestled at 15 Jefferson Ave. in the heart of downtown. Serving classic, handcrafted pizzas with a nod to bold, family-favorite flavors, it combines a casual, social atmosphere with quick, friendly service. Enjoy a skyline view from the dining area, savor pepperoni perfection or inventive pies, and pair your meal with fresh, chef-curated toppings and neighborhood hospitality. A staple for locals and visitors alike, Spankey's Una Pizza Downtown delivers comforting pizza, tasty bites, and a warm, laid-back vibe.
Show more
Steve's Una Pizza
Steve's Una Pizza is a cozy, family-friendly pizzeria located at 1005 S St James Blvd in Evansville, IN. Known for its authentic, hand-tossed crust, flavorful sauces, and generous toppings, this neighborhood staple serves up classic Italian favorites, fresh salads, and savory fazzoletti pies. Friendly service, quick curbside pickup, and a welcoming atmosphere make Steve's Una Pizza a go-to spot for a comforting, delicious slice or a hearty family meal.
Show more
The Slice
The Slice at 2011 Lincoln Ave in Evansville offers a cozy, modern dining experience with crave-worthy, house-made pizzas, fresh toppings, and artisan slices. Nestled in a welcoming neighborhood setting, this spot combines quick casual service with flavorful, generously priced options perfect for a casual lunch, a casual dinner, or a late-night bite. Enjoy a rotating lineup of specialties, craft beverages, and a warm, neighborhood vibe that keeps locals returning for reliable, tasty pizza and friendly service.
Show more
Turoni's Pizzery & Brewery
Turoni's Pizzery & Brewery, located at 8011 Bell Oaks Dr, Newburgh, IN 47630, USA, blends craft beer with hearty, flavorful pizza in a welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere. Enjoy a rotating lineup of house-brewed ales and lagers alongside classic favorites, all made with quality ingredients and a commitment to community. Whether soaking up a game-day vibe, sharing a slice with friends, or exploring their handmade pizzas and signature brews, Turoni's offers a warm, Midwest-style dining experience with a touch of local charm.
Show more
Turoni's Pizzery & Brewery
Turoni’s Pizzery & Brewery, located at 408 N Main St in Evansville, Indiana, blends family‑friendly pizza joy with craft beer handcrafted on site. Savor brick‑oven pies, classic tavern favorites, and a welcoming, neighborhood atmosphere where friends gather, birthdays are celebrated, and local brews pair perfectly with tasty slices.
Show more
Twisted Tomato - North Side
Twisted Tomato - North Side is a vibrant neighborhood eatery at 2333 St George Rd in Evansville, IN. Known for its creative, locally inspired dishes and chef-driven twists, the restaurant offers a welcoming atmosphere, fresh ingredients, and bold flavors that celebrate the heart of Indiana cuisine. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick lunch or savoring a dinner with friends, Twisted Tomato - North Side delivers inventive plates, craft beverages, and friendly, attentive service in a casual, modern setting.
Show more